• Authentication, Authorization, and Access Control

    Apache has three distinct ways of dealing with the question of whether a particular request for a resource will result in that resource actually be returned. These criteria are called Authorization, Authentication, and Access control.

    Authentication is any process by which you verify that someone is who they claim they are. This usually involves a username and a password, but can include any other method of demonstrating identity, such as a smart card, retina scan, voice recognition, or fingerprints. Authentication is equivalent to showing your drivers license at the ticket counter at the airport.

    Authorization is finding out if the person, once identified, is permitted to have the resource. This is usually determined by finding out if that person is a part of a particular group, if that person has paid admission, or has a particular level of security clearance. Authorization is equivalent to checking the guest list at an exclusive party, or checking for your ticket when you go to the opera.

    Finally, access control is a much more general way of talking about controlling access to a web resource. Access can be granted or denied based on a wide variety of criteria, such as the network address of the client, the time of day, the phase of the moon, or the browser which the visitor is using. Access control is analogous to locking the gate at closing time, or only letting people onto the ride who are more than 48 inches tall – it’s controlling entrance by some arbitrary condition which may or may not have anything to do with the attributes of the particular visitor.

    Because these three techniques are so closely related in most real applications, it is difficult to talk about them separate from one another. In particular, authentication and authorization are, in most actual implementations, inextricable.

    If you have information on your web site that is sensitive, or intended for only a small group of people, the techniques in this tutorial will help you make sure that the people that see those pages are the people that you wanted to see them.

    Basic authentication

    As the name implies, basic authentication is the simplest method of authentication, and for a long time was the most common authentication method used. However, other methods of authentication have recently passed basic in common usage, due to usability issues that will be discussed in a minute.

    How basic authentication works

    When a particular resource has been protected using basic authentication, Apache sends a 401 Authentication Required header with the response to the request, in order to notify the client that user credentials must be supplied in order for the resource to be returned as requested.

    Upon receiving a 401 response header, the client’s browser, if it supports basic authentication, will ask the user to supply a username and password to be sent to the server. If you are using a graphical browser, such as Netscape or Internet Explorer, what you will see is a box which pops up and gives you a place to type in your username and password, to be sent back to the server. If the username is in the approved list, and if the password supplied is correct, the resource will be returned to the client.

    Because the HTTP protocol is stateless, each request will be treated in the same way, even though they are from the same client. That is, every resource which is requested from the server will have to supply authentication credentials over again in order to receive the resource.

    Fortunately, the browser takes care of the details here, so that you only have to type in your username and password one time per browser session – that is, you might have to type it in again the next time you open up your browser and visit the same web site.

    Along with the 401 response, certain other information will be passed back to the client. In particular, it sends a name which is associated with the protected area of the web site. This is called the realm, or just the authentication name. The client browser caches the username and password that you supplied, and stores it along with the authentication realm, so that if other resources are requested from the same realm, the same username and password can be returned to authenticate that request without requiring the user to type them in again. This caching is usually just for the current browser session, but some browsers allow you to store them permanently, so that you never have to type in your password again.

    The authentication name, or realm, will appear in the pop-up box, in order to identify what the username and password are being requested for.

    Configuration: Protecting content with basic authentication

    There are two configuration steps which you must complete in order to protect a resource using basic authentication. Or three, depending on what you are trying to do.

    1. Create a password file
    2. Set the configuration to use this password file
    3. Optionally, create a group file

    Create a password file

    In order to determine whether a particular username/password combination is valid, the username and password supplied by the user will need to be compared to some authoritative listing of usernames and password. This is the password file, which you will need to create on the server side, and populate with valid users and their passwords.

    Because this file contains sensitive information, it should be stored outside of the document directory. Although, as you will see in a moment, the passwords are encrypted in the file, if a cracker were to gain access to the file, it would be an aid in their attempt to figure out the passwords. And, because people tend to be sloppy with the passwords that they choose, and use the same password for web site authentication as for their bank account, this potentially be a very serious breach of security, even if the content on your web site is not particularly sensitive.

    Caution: Encourage your users to use a different password for your web site than for other more essential things. For example, many people tend to use two passwords – one for all of their extremely important things, such as the login to their desktop computer, and for their bank account, and another for less sensitive things, the compromise of which would be less serious.

    To create the password file, use the htpasswd utility that came with Apache. This will be located in the bin directory of wherever you installed Apache. For example, it will probably be located at/usr/local/apache/bin/htpasswd if you installed Apache from source.

    To create the file, type:

    htpasswd -c /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords username

    htpasswd will ask you for the password, and then ask you to type it again to confirm it:

    # htpasswd -c /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords rbowen
    New password: mypassword
    Re-type new password: mypassword
    Adding password for user rbowen

    Note that in the example shown, a password file is being created containing a user called rbowen, and this password file is being placed in the location /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords. You will substitute the location, and the username, which you want to use to start your password file.

    If htpasswd is not in your path, you will have to type the full path to the file to get it to run. That is, in the example above, you would replace htpasswd with /usr/local/apache/bin/htpasswd

    The -c flag is used only when you are creating a new file. After the first time, you will omit the -c flag, when you are adding new users to an already-existing password file.

    htpasswd /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords sungo

    The example just shown will add a user named sungo to a password file which has already been created earlier. As before, you will be asked for the password at the command line, and then will be asked to confirm the password by typing it again.

    Caution: Be very careful when you add new users to an existing password file that you don’t use the -c flag by mistake. Using the -c flag will create a new password file, even if you already have an existing file of that name. That is, it will remove the contents of the file that is there, and replace it with a new file containing only the one username which you were adding.

    The password is stored in the password file in encrypted form, so that users on the system will not be able to read the file and immediately determine the passwords of all the users. Nevertheless, you should store the file in as secure a location as possible, with whatever minimum permissions on the file so that the web server itself can read the file. For example, if your server is configured to run as user nobody and group nogroup, then you should set permissions on the file so that only the webserver can read the file and only root can write to it:

    chown root.nogroup /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords
    chmod 640 /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords

    On Windows, a similar precaution should be taken, changing the ownership of the password file to the web server user, so that other users cannot read the file.

    Set the configuration to use this password file

    Once you have created the password file, you need to tell Apache about it, and tell Apache to use this file in order to require user credentials for admission. This configuration is done with the following directives:

    AuthType Authentication type being used. In this case, it will be set toBasic
    AuthName The authentication realm or name
    AuthUserFile The location of the password file
    AuthGroupFile The location of the group file, if any
    Require The requirement(s) which must be satisfied in order to grant admission

    These directives may be placed in a .htaccess file in the particular directory being protected, or may go in the main server configuration file, in a <Directory> section, or other scope container.

    The example shown below defines an authentication realm called “By Invitation Only”. The password file located at /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords will be used to verify the user’s identity. Only users namedrbowen or sungo will be granted access, and even then only if they provide a password which matches the password stored in the password file.

    AuthType Basic
    AuthName "By Invitation Only"
    AuthUserFile /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords
    Require user rbowen sungo

    The phrase “By Invitation Only” will be displayed in the password pop-up box, where the user will have to type their credentials.

    You will need to restart your Apache server in order for the new configuration to take effect, if these directives were put in the main server configuration file. Directives placed in .htaccess files take effect immediately, since .htaccess files are parsed each time files are served.

    The next time that you load a file from that directory, you will see the familiar username/password dialog box pop up, requiring that you type the username and password before you are permitted to proceed.

    Note that in addition to specifically listing the users to whom you want to grant access, you can specify that any valid user should be let in. This is done with the valid-user keyword:

    Require valid-user

    Optionally, create a group file

    Most of the time, you will want more than one, or two, or even a dozen, people to have access to a resource. You want to be able to define a group of people that have access to that resource, and be able to manage that group of people, adding and removing members, without having to edit the server configuration file, and restart Apache, each time.

    This is handled using authentication groups. An authentication group is, as you would expect, a group name associated with a list of members. This list is stored in a group file, which should be stored in the same location as the password file, so that you are able to keep track of these things.

    The format of the group file is exceedingly simple. A group name appears first on a line, followed by a colon, and then a list of the members of the group, separated by spaces. For example:

    authors: rich daniel allan

    Once this file has been created, you can Require that someone be in a particular group in order to get the requested resource. This is done with the AuthGroupFile directive, as shown in the following example.

    AuthType Basic
    AuthName "Apache Admin Guide Authors"
    AuthUserFile /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords
    AuthGroupFile /usr/local/apache/passwd/groups
    Require group authors

    The authentication process is now one step more involved. When a request is received, and the requested username and password are supplied, the group file is first checked to see if the supplied username is even in the required group. If it is, then the password file will be checked to see if the username is in there, and if the supplied password matches the password stored in that file. If any of these steps fail, access will be forbidden.

    Frequently asked questions about basic auth

    The following questions tend to get asked very frequently with regard to basic authentication. It should be understood that basic authentication is very basic, and so is limited to the set of features that has been presented above. Most of the more interesting things that people tend to want, need to be implemented using some alternate authentication scheme.

    How do I log out?

    Since browsers first started implementing basic authentication, website administrators have wanted to know how to let the user log out. Since the browser caches the username and password with the authentication realm, as described earlier in this tutorial, this is not a function of the server configuration, but is a question of getting the browser to forget the credential information, so that the next time the resource is requested, the username and password must be supplied again. There are numerous situations in which this is desirable, such as when using a browser in a public location, and not wishing to leave the browser logged in, so that the next person can get into your bank account.

    However, although this is perhaps the most frequently asked question about basic authentication, thus far none of the major browser manufacturers have seen this as being a desirable feature to put into their products.

    Consequently, the answer to this question is, you can’t. Sorry.

    How can I change what the password box looks like?

    The dialog that pops up for the user to enter their username and password is ugly. It contains text that you did not indicate that you wanted in there. It looks different in Internet Explorer and Netscape, and contains different text. And it asks for fields that the user might not understand – for example, Netscape asks the user to type in their “User ID”, and they might not know what that means. Or, you might want to provide additional explanatory text so that the user has a better idea what is going on.

    Unfortunately, these things are features of the browser, and cannot be controlled from the server side. If you want the login to look different, then you will need to implement your own authentication scheme. There is no way to change what this login box looks like if you are using basic authentication.

    How to I make it not ask me for my password the next time?

    Because most browsers store your password information only for the current browser session, when you close your browser it forgets your username and password. So, when you visit the same web site again, you will need to re-enter your username and password.

    There is nothing that can be done about this on the server side.

    However, the most recent versions of the major browsers contain the ability to remember your password forever, so that you never have to log in again. While it is debatable whether this is a good idea, since it effectively overrides the entire point of having security in the first place, it is certainly convenient for the user, and simplifies the user experience.

    Why does it sometimes ask me for my password twice?

    When entering a password-protected web site for the first time, you will occasionally notice that you are asked for your password twice. This may happen immediately after you entered the password the first time, or it may happen when you click on the first link after authenticating the first time.

    This happens for a very simple, but nonetheless confusing, reason, again having to do with the way that the browser caches the login information.

    Login information is stored on the browser based on the authentication realm, specified by the AuthName directive, and by the server name. In this way, the browser can distinguish between the Private authentication realm on one site and on another. So, if you go to a site using one name for the server, and internal links on the server refer to that server by a different name, the browser has no way to know that they are in fact the same server.

    For example, if you were to visit the URL http://example.com/private/, which required authentication, your browser would remember the supplied username and password, associated with the hostnameexample.com. If, by virtue of an internal redirect, or fully-qualified HTML links in pages, you are then sent to the URL http://www.example.com/private/, even though this is really exactly the same URL, the browser does not know this for sure, and is forced to request the authentication information again, since example.com and www.example.com are not exactly the same hostname. Your browser has no particular way to know that these are the same web site.

    Security caveat

    Basic authentication should not be considered secure for any particularly rigorous definition of secure.

    Although the password is stored on the server in encrypted format, it is passed from the client to the server in plain text across the network. Anyone listening with any variety of packet sniffer will be able to read the username and password in the clear as it goes across.

    Not only that, but remember that the username and password are passed with every request, not just when the user first types them in. So the packet sniffer need not be listening at a particularly strategic time, but just for long enough to see any single request come across the wire.

    And, in addition to that, the content itself is also going across the network in the clear, and so if the web site contains sensitive information, the same packet sniffer would have access to that information as it went past, even if the username and password were not used to gain direct access to the web site.

    Don’t use basic authentication for anything that requires real security. It is a detriment for most users, since very few people will take the trouble, or have the necessary software and/or equipment, to find out passwords. However, if someone had a desire to get in, it would take very little for them to do so.

    Digest authentication

    Addressing one of the security caveats of basic authentication, digest authentication provides an alternate method for protecting your web content. However, it to has a few caveats.

    How digest auth works

    Digest authentication is implemented by the module mod_auth_digest. There is an older module, mod_digest, which implemented an older version of the digest authentication specification, but which will probably not work with newer browsers.

    Using digest authentication, your password is never sent across the network in the clear, but is always transmitted as an MD5 digest of the user’s password. In this way, the password cannot be determined by sniffing network traffic.

    The full specification of digest authentication can be seen in the internet standards document RFC 2617, which you can see at http://www1.ics.uci.edu/pub/ietf/http/rfc2617.txt. Additional information and resources about MD5 can be found at http://userpages.umbc.edu/ mabzug1/cs/md5/md5.html

    Configuration: Protecting content with digest authentication

    The steps for configuring your server for digest authentication are very similar for those for basic authentication.

    1. Create the password file
    2. Set the configuration to use this password file
    3. Optionally, create a group file

    Creating a password file

    As with basic authentication, a simple utility is provided to create and maintain the password file which will be used to determine whether a particular user’s name and password are valid. This utility is called htdigest, and will be located in the bin directory of wherever you installed Apache. If you installed Apache from some variety of package manager, htdigest is likely to have been placed somewhere in your path.

    To create a new digest password file, type:

    htdigest -c /usr/local/apache/passwd/digest realm username

    htdigest will ask you for the desired password, and then ask you to type it again to confirm it.

    Note that the realm for which the authentication will be required is part of the argument list.

    Once again, as with basic authentication, you are encouraged to place the generated file somewhere outside of the document directory.

    And, as with the htpasswd utility, the -c flag creates a new file, or, if a file of that name already exists, deletes the contents of that file and generates a new file in its place. Omit the -c flag in order to add new user information to an existing password file.

    Set the configuration to use this password file

    Once you have created a password file, you need to tell Apache about it in order to start using it as a source of authenticated user information. This configuration is done with the following directives:

    AuthType Authentication type being used. In this case, it will be set toDigest
    AuthName The authentication realm or name
    AuthDigestFile The location of the password file
    AuthDigestGroupFile Location of the group file, if any
    Require The requirement(s) which must be satisfied in order to grant admission

    These directives may be placed in a .htaccess file in the particular directory being protected, or may go in the main server configuration file, in a <Directory> section, or another scope container.

    The following example defines an authentication realm called “Private”. The password file located at /usr/local/apache/passwd/digest will be used to verify the user’s identity. Only users named drbacchus ordorfl will be granted access, if they provide a password that patches the password stored in the password file.

    AuthType Digest
    AuthName "Private"
    AuthDigestFile /usr/local/apache/passwd/digest
    Require user drbacchus dorfl

    The phrase “Private” will be displayed in the password pop-up box, where the user will have to type their credentials.

    Optionally, create a group file

    As you have observed, there are not many differences between this configuration process and that required by basic authentication, described in the previous section. This is true also of group functionality. The group file used for digest authentication is exactly the same as that used for basic authentication. That is to say, lines in the group file consist the name of the group, a colon, and a list of the members of that group. For example:

    admins: jim roy ed anne

    Once this file has been created, you can Require that someone be in a particular group in order to get the requested resource. This is done with the AuthDigestGroupFile directive, as shown in the following example.

    AuthType Digest
    AuthName "Private"
    AuthDigestFile /usr/local/apache/passwd/digest
    AuthDigestGroupFile /usr/local/apache/passwd/digest.groups
    Require group admins

    The authentication process is the same as that used by basic authentication. It is first verified that the user is in the required group, and, if this is true, then the password is verified.


    Before you leap into using digest authentication instead of basic authentication, there are a few things that you should know about.

    Most importantly, you need to know that, although digest authentication has this great advantage that you don’t send your password across the network in the clear, it is not supported by all major browsers in use today, and so you should not use it on a web site on which you cannot control the browsers that people will be using, such as on your intranet site. In particular, Opera 4.0 or later, Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.0 or later, Mozilla 1.0.1 and Netscape 7 or later as well as Amaya support digest authentication, while various other browsers do not.

    Next, with regard to security considerations, you should understand two things. Although your password is not passed in the clear, all of your data is, and so this is a rather small measure of security. And, although your password is not really sent at all, but a digest form of it, someone very familiar with the workings of HTTP could use that information – just your digested password – and use that to gain access to the content, since that digested password is really all the information required to access the web site.

    The moral of this is that if you have content that really needs to be kept secure, use SSL.

    Database authentication modules

    Basic authentication and digest authentication both suffer from the same major flaw. They use text files to store the authentication information. The problem with this is that looking something up in a text file is very slow. It’s rather like trying to find something in a book that has no index. You have to start at the beginning, and work through it one page at a time until you find what you are looking for. Now imagine that the next time you need to find the same thing, you don’t remember where it was before, so you have to start at the beginning again, and work through one page at a time until you find it again. And the next time. And the time after that.

    Since HTTP is stateless, authentication has to be verified every time that content is requested. And so every time a document is accessed which is secured with basic or digest authentication, Apache has to open up those text password files and look through them one line at a time, until it finds the user that is trying to log in, and verifies their password. In the worst case, if the username supplied is not in there at all, every line in the file will need to be checked. On average, half of the file will need to be read before the user is found. This is very slow.

    While this is not a big problem for small sets of users, when you get into larger numbers of users (where “larger” means a few hundred) this becomes prohibitively slow. In many cases, in fact, valid username/password combinations will get rejected because the authentication module just had to spend so much time looking for the username in the file that Apache will just get tired of waiting and return a failed authentication.

    In these cases, you need an alternative, and that alternative is to use some variety of database. Databases are optimized for looking for a particular piece of information in a very large data set. It builds indexes in order to rapidly locate a particular record, and they have query languages for swiftly locating records that match particular criteria.

    There are numerous modules available for Apache to authenticate using a variety of different databases. In this section, we’ll just look at two modules which ship with Apache.

    mod_auth_db and mod_auth_dbm

    mod_auth_db and mod_auth_dbm are modules which lets you keep your usernames and passwords in DB or DBM files. There are few practical differences between DB files and DBM files. And, on some operating systems, such as various BSDs, and Linux, they are exactly the same thing. You should pick whichever of the two modules makes the most sense on your particular platform of choice. If you do not have DB support on your platform, you may need to install it. You download an implementation of DB at http://www.sleepycat.com/.

    Berkeley DB files

    DB files, also known as Berkeley database files, are the simplest form of database, and are rather ideally suited for the sort of data that needs to be stored for HTTP authentication. DB files store key/value pairs. That is, the name of a variable, and the value of that variable. While other databases allow the storage of many fields in a given record, a DB file allows only this pairing of key and value.1 This is ideal for authentication, which requires only the pair of a username and password.

    Installing mod_auth_db

    For the purposes of this tutorial, we’ll talk about installing and configuring mod_auth_db. However, everything that is said here can be directly applied to mod_auth_dbm by simply replacing ‘db’ with ‘dbm’ and ‘DB’ with ‘DBM’ in the various commands, file names, and directives.

    Since mod_auth_db is not compiled in by default, you will need to rebuild Apache in order to get the functionality, unless you built in everything when we started. Note that if you installed Apache with shared object support, you may be able to just build the module and load it in to Apache.

    To build Apache from scratch with mod_auth_db built in, use the following ./configure line in your apache source code directory.

    ./configure --enable-module=auth_db

    Or, if you had a more complex configure command line, you can just add the -enable-module=auth_db option to that command line, and you’ll get mod_auth_db built into your server.

    Protecting a directory with mod_auth_db

    Once you have compiled the mod_auth_db module, and loaded it into your web server, you’ll find that there’s very little difference between using regular authentication and using mod_auth_db authentication. The procedure is the same as that we went through with basic and digest authentication:

    1. Create the user file.
    2. Configure Apache to use that file for authentication.
    3. Optionally, create a group file.

    Create the user file

    The user file for authentication is, this time, not a flat text file, but is a DB file2. Fortunately, once again, Apache provides us with a simple utility for the purpose of managing this user file. This time, the utility is calleddbmmanage, and will be located in the bin subdirectory of wherever you installed Apache.

    dbmmanage is somewhat more complicated to use than htpasswd or htdigest, but it is still fairly simple. The syntax which you will usually be using is as follows:

    dbmmanage passwords.dat adduser montressor

    As with htpasswd, you will at this point be prompted for a password, and then asked to confirm that password by typing it again. The main difference here is that rather than a text file being created, you are creating a binary file containing the information that you have supplied.

    Type dbmmanage with no arguments to get the full list of options available with this utility.

    Creating your user file with Perl

    Note that, if you are so inclined, you can manage your user file with Perl, or any other language which has a DB-file module, for interfacing with this type of database. This covers a number of popular programming languages.

    The following Perl code, for example, will add a user ‘rbowen’, with password ‘mypassword’, to your password file:

    use DB_File;
    tie %database, 'DB_File', "passwords.dat"
        or die "Can't initialize database: $!\n";
    $username = 'rbowen';
    $password = 'mypassword';
    $salt = $chars[int rand @chars] . $chars[int rand @chars];
    $crypt = crypt($password, $salt);
    $database{$username} = $crypt;
    untie %database;

    As you can imagine, this makes it very simple to write tools to manage the user and password information stored in these files.

    Passwords are stored in Unix crypt format, just as they were in the “regular” password files. The ‘salt’ that is created in the middle there is part of the process, generating a random starting point for that encryption. The technique being used is called a ‘tied hash’. The idea is to tie a built-in data structure to the contents of the file, such that when the data structure is changed, the file is automatically modified at the same time.

    Configuring Apache to use this password file

    Once you have created the password file, you need to tell Apache about it, and tell Apache to use this file to verify user credentials. This configuration will look almost the same as that for basic authentication. This configuration can go in a .htaccess file in the directory to be protected, or can go in the main server configuration, in a <Directory> section, or other scope container directive.

    The configuration will look something like the following:

    AuthName "Members Only"
    AuthType Basic
    AuthDBUserFile /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords.dat
    require user rbowen

    Now, users accessing the directory will be required to authenticate against the list of valid users who are in /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords.dat.

    Optionally, create a group file

    As mentioned earlier, DB files store a key/value pair. In the case of group files, the key is the name of the user, and the value is a comma-separated list of the groups to which the user belongs.

    While this is the opposite of the way that group files are stored elsewhere, note that we will primarily be looking up records based on the username, so it is more efficient to index the file by username, rather than by the group name.

    Groups can be added to your group file using dbmmanage and the add command:

    dbmmanage add groupfile rbowen one,two,three

    In the above example, groupfile is the literal name of the group file, rbowen is the user being added, and one, two, and three are names of three groups to which this user belongs.

    Once you have your groups in the file, you can require a group in the regular way:

    AuthName "Members Only"
    AuthType Basic
    AuthDBUserFile /usr/local/apache/passwd/passwords.dat
    AuthDBGroupFile /usr/local/apache/passwd/groups.dat
    require group three

    Note that if you want to use the same file for both password and group information, you can do so, but this is a little more complicated to manage, as you have to encrypt the password yourself before you feed it to thedbmmanage utility.

    Access control

    Authentication by username and password is only part of the story. Frequently you want to let people in based on something other than who they are. Something such as where they are coming from. Restricting access based on something other than the identity of the user is generally referred to as Access Control.

    Allow and Deny

    The Allow and Deny directives let you allow and deny access based on the host name, or host address, of the machine requesting a document. The directive goes hand-in-hand with these is the Order directive, which tells Apache in which order to apply the filters.

    The usage of these directives is:

    allow from address

    where address is an IP address (or a partial IP address) or a fully qualified domain name (or a partial domain name); you may provide multiple addresses or domain names, if desired.

    For example, if you have someone spamming your message board, and you want to keep them out, you could do the following:

    deny from

    Visitors coming from that address will not be able to see the content behind this directive. If, instead, you have a machine name, rather than an IP address, you can use that.

    deny from hostname.example.com

    And, if you’d like to block access from an entire domain, or even from an entire tld (top level domain, such as .com or .gov) you can specify just part of an address or domain name:

    deny from 192.101.205
    deny from exampleone.com exampletwo.com
    deny from tld

    Using Order will let you be sure that you are actually restricting things to the group that you want to let in, by combining a deny and an allow directive:

    Order Deny,Allow
    Deny from all
    Allow from hostname.example.com

    Listing just the allow directive would not do what you want, because it will let users from that host in, in addition to letting everyone in. What you want is to let in only users from that host.


    The Satisfy directive can be used to specify that several criteria may be considered when trying to decide if a particular user will be granted admission. Satisfy can take as an argument one of two options – all or any. By default, it is assumed that the value is all. This means that if several criteria are specified, then all of them must be met in order for someone to get in. However, if set to any, then several criteria may be specified, but if the user satisfies any of these, then they will be granted entrance.

    A very good example of this is using access control to assure that, although a resource is password protected from outside your network, all hosts inside the network will be given free access to the resource. This would be accomplished by using the Satisfy directive, as shown below.

    <Directory /usr/local/apache/htdocs/sekrit>
      AuthType Basic
      AuthName intranet
      AuthUserFile /www/passwd/users
      AuthGroupFile /www/passwd/groups
      Require group customers
      Order allow,deny
      Allow from internal.com
      Satisfy any

    In this scenario, users will be let in if they either have a password, or if they are in the internal network.


    The various authentication modules provide a number of ways to restrict access to your host based on the identity of the user. They offer a somewhat standard interface to this functionality, but provide different back-end mechanisms for actually authenticating the user.

    And the access control mechanism allows you to restrict access based on criteria unrelated to the identity of the user.


    … value.1
    There are actually a number of implementations that get around this limitation. MLDBM is one of them, for example. However, for the purposes of this discussion, we’ll just deal with standard Berkeley DB, which is likely to have shipped with whatever operating system you are already running.
    … file2
    Or, if you are using mod_auth_dbm, a DBM file.

Comments are closed.